This page looks different to our usual site because it is from our back catalogue. More recent articles are here.


New York has failed its carriage horses - report

A carriage horse pictured in New York on Saturday.

September 11, 2007

New York City's carriage horse industry is in for a shakeup after a report by the city's comptroller said the city must take its role in ensuring the welfare of the horses more seriously.

In the audit released in June, New York City Comptroller William C. Thompson, Jr. called on the City departments of Consumer affairs and Health and Mental Hygiene to strengthen their oversight of the City's carriage-horse industry.

In the past several years there have been many accidents between carriages and vehicles, which in some cases have resulted in horse deaths. Recent incidents include a collision in July, and another in June. Horses were injured in both incidents.

The audit has renewed calls for a ban on the carriage horse industry.

"This report simply confirms what we have said all along: that it is impossible for this industry to operate humanely in NYC. Drivers continuously disobey the law and there is no one (ASPCA, DoH or DCA) there to stop them," said a spokesman for the lobby group Coalition to Ban Horse Drawn Carriages.

"The carriage-horse industry is an important part of our City's charm and appeal for New Yorkers and tourists alike," Thompson said. "The City must take its role more seriously to ensure the health and well-being of carriage-horses and the regulation of the industry in general."

He also suggested an area within Central Park to house both carriage and pleasure horses: "Not only would this serve as a popular attraction, but it would keep the horses away from city traffic and allow their health and welfare to be more easily monitored."

But this has met with disapproval from the Coalition to Ban Horse Drawn Carriages: "Horses would still be stuck between the shafts of their carriages for nine hours straight and continue to be the victims of forced labour. Suggesting that the stables be built in Central Park is irresponsible and not well thought out. It is not only a landmark but the Central Park Conservancy is opposed to it. It would take up to two acres of land and would still be run by the same incompetent agencies and owners. Our Coalition is campaigning for an end to the horse-drawn carriage industry in NYC on the grounds that it is inhumane to the horses and is a safety and traffic issue for humans."

The New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH) and the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) are responsible for overseeing and licensing the horses, carriage-horse drivers, carriages and stables. DOHMH's Veterinary Public Health Services (VPHS) reviews and approves carriage-horse license applications and Certificates of Health stating that horses are able to work.

Thompson's audit analyzed whether DOHMH and DCA had adequate controls over the licensing of carriage-horses, drivers, carriages, stables, and comply with the City's applicable rules and regulations. The audit covered July 1, 2005 to March 30, 2007.

The audit determined that, for more than 25 years, DOHMH has failed to create a City-required Advisory Board, which could help to ensure that rules overseeing the industry are current and cover topics such as the size of horse stalls and age limits for horses.

"With the lack of such a board, regulations promoting the health, safety, and well-being of the carriage-horses remain broad and general in scope," Thompson said. "DOHMH, for example, has no written guidelines regarding when and how often stables should be inspected. The agency's veterinarian consultant only visited each of the stables five times in calendar year 2006 and did not even examine the condition of any horses in the field."

During the audit certain issues were brought to the auditors' attention by the carriage-horse owners/drivers and American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) officials that affect the well-being of the horses, such as: no established hack stands (areas identifying where carriages may pick up passengers); no water spigots in areas where carriages wait to pick up passengers; inadequate drainage where horses line up, leaving horses to stand in pools of dirty water; and, materials such as concrete should be considered to replace asphalt where horses lineup because it becomes very hot during the summer. These, as well as other issues, could be addressed by the Advisory Board.

Additionally, while DOHMH and DCA have regulatory responsibilities, the ASPCA has voluntarily stepped in to perform much more monitoring over the last few years. ASPCA officials told auditors they took it upon themselves to increase their oversight of the carriage-horse industry because they witnessed a decline in monitoring by the City. DOHMH and DCA rely on the ASPCA to voluntarily perform inspections of the stables and of the horses, drivers, and carriages in the field, which ASPCA performs without a formal agreement.

"Without a formal agreement, DOHMH and DCA have relied upon yet have no control over the ASPCA's voluntary monitoring activities," Thompson said. "Since there is no official agreement regarding inspections, it is possible that the ASPCA may need to reduce or curtail its activities at some point, leaving a void in the oversight of the industry."

During Fiscal Year 2006, there were about 221 licensed horses, 293 licensed drivers, and 68 licensed carriages that provided horse-drawn carriage rides to the public.

Additionally, Thompson's auditors uncovered the following:

Auditors, however, did cite some positive findings. Auditors made unannounced visits to hack lines adjacent to Central Park and found that carriages had current license plates, horses had brass tags with identification numbers that matched the numbers branded into the hooves, and drivers held current driver's licenses.

Additionally, DOHMH files contained the required training program and examinations to drivers of horse-drawn carriages and maintained the Certificates of Health for the horses. DCA files showed that it issued and renewed licenses to horses, carriages, and drivers.

Comptroller Thompson made several recommendations, including the establishment of regulations to promote the health, safety and well-being of the carriage-horses, and the need for guidelines on the regularity of veterinary inspections of horses at work and in their stables.


Get article updates - equine research and information


Affiliate disclaimer