Brumbies can fill a useful role in Australian ecosystems, says ecologist

Brumbies graze near a dirt road. Photo: Kersti Nebelsiek assumed, Public domain via Wikimedia Commons
Brumbies graze near a dirt road. Photo: Kersti Nebelsiek assumed, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

American wildlife ecologist Craig Downer says wild horses and donkeys can make valuable contributions to Australian ecosystems in many different ways. He described them in this poster presentation at the Ecological Society of Australia annual conference in 2014.

Wild horses can complement an ecosystem, or life community, in many direct and obvious as well as more subtle ways. This they do when permitted their natural freedom to move and interrelate over a sufficiently extensive intact habitat and time period.

Dietary benefits, buildings, dispersing viable seeds

Equids possess a caecal, or post-gastric, digestive system. This enables them to take advantage of coarser, drier vegetation and, through symbiotic microbial activity, to break down cellulose cell walls to derive sufficient nutrients from the inner cell without overtaxing their metabolism. In drier regions, this can give equids a distinct advantage.

Consumption by equids of coarser, drier vegetation can greatly benefit sympatric, pre-gastric (ruminant) herbivores, and energize and enrich the ecosystem as a whole. By recycling chiefly the coarse, dry grasses as well as other dry, withered herbs, forbs and bush foliage, the horses and burros expose the seedlings of many diverse species to more sun, water and air, thus permitting them to flourish. The latter can then be consumed by ruminants (see R.H.V. Bell 1970).

Of great importance is the contribution by wild equids of significant quantities of partially degraded vegetation in the form of feces deposited on the land. These droppings provide fodder for myriad soil microorganisms; the resulting fecal decomposition builds the humus component of soils, lending ecologically valuable texture and cohesiveness. As feces slowly decompose, they gradually release their nutrients over all seasons and, thus, feed the fungal garden that exists in soils, thereby increasing the soil’s absorption of water – that vital limiting factor in semi-arid and arid regions.

Equid feces lend more sustenance to decomposers and food webs that involve mutually sustaining exchanges among all classes of organisms. The latter include many diverse insects, birds, rodents, reptiles, etc. This could help bolster many native species in Australia.

The less degraded feces of equids contain many more seeds that are intact and capable of germination and from many more types/species of plants when compared with ruminant grazers. Thus, the horses’ wide-ranging lifestyles can greatly assist many plants, including Australian natives, in dispersing far and wide and, so, in filling their respective ecological niches. This enriches the food web and allows a greater diversity of animal species, including Australian natives.

Behavioral benefits

Horses aid myriad plant and animal species by their physical actions. As an example, breaking of ice with their hooves during winter freezes allows other animals to access forage and water. Many of these would otherwise perish. Similarly, they open trails in heavy snow or through heavy brush, allowing smaller animals to move about in search of food, water, mineral salts, shelter, warmer areas, mates, etc.

A little-recognized fact is that the wallowing habit of wild equids creates natural ponds whose impacted surfaces become catchments for scant precipitation or summer cloudbursts. These provide a longer-lasting source of water for a wide diversity of plants and animals. This can even help to create an intermittent riparian habitat for desert amphibians and many other desert species including those of the Australian Outback. Ephemeral plants that quickly flower and set seed, including many composites, are benefited from these catchments – especially valuable in regions with clayey soils.

Wild horses also locate water seeps through their keen sense of smell and enlarge these through pawing during critical dry periods of the year, even digging down to the sources at rocky fissures. This allows many other species to access water, species whose individual members would otherwise perish. For these and many other reasons, wild equids should be treated as keystone species that contribute positively in a variety of ecological settings.

Role as prey

Wild horses are natural prey of certain carnivores and omnivores including in Australia dingoes, crocodiles, and wild dog packs.

Brumbies graze in Kakadu National Park. Photo: Cgoodwin, CC BY 3.0, from Wikimedia Commons
Brumbies graze in Kakadu National Park. Photo: Cgoodwin, CC BY 3.0, from Wikimedia Commons

Suitability to arid and semi-arid ecosystems

Wild horses and donkeys are well suited to life in arid and semi-arid ecosystems. One reason is obvious: their great mobility. With their long limbs and sturdy, single-unit (soliped) hooves, they are made for movement. In such semi-arid or arid regions, this extensive movement is vital for survival. In order to obtain enough forage, a wild horse must often roam over several square miles each day, selecting appropriate plants to prune; reaching a water hole may involve traveling over a hundred-mile round trip in a grazing circuit of two or three days. Wild horses do not camp on riparian habitats as do cattle.

During very hot, dry spells, a wild horse band must stay close to water, tanking up every day with about 10 to 12 gallons for a mature horse. A spring can be shared by several bands. These form an orderly hierarchy for watering should more than one band arrive at a source at the same time, often late in the day. When melting snow or fresh cloudbursts paint the land with ephemeral water sources, wild horses can disperse into areas further away from perennial lakes and streams and to these ephemeral sources. Here they employ their keen sense of smell in detecting even very small and hidden water sources. They can also negotiate rougher, steeper, and rockier terrain than domestic cattle, and prevent flammable vegetation from building up there.

Through a hammer-like hoof action upon the ground, wild equids aid vegetation by pushing seeds firmly into the soil where they may successfully germinate. Their feces also provide a fertile bed for the germination of seeds.

Equids’ post-gastric digestive system in relation to global warming

The horse’s post-gastric digestive system does not emit as much gas as is the case with pre-gastric ruminant grazers, and permits them to greatly reduce dry, fire-prone vegetation over vast areas without overtaxing their metabolism. Thus, they help to prevent catastrophic fires that global warming, or more to the point, human civilization’s pollution of the atmosphere, is causing.

By drying out vegetation and provoking catastrophic fires – rampant in western and southern North America, Australia, and much of the world – the catch-all “global climate change” threatens planetary life as we know it. This will especially be the case if global ocean currents stop circulating because of glacial and ice cap melting, etc. Wild equids can greatly help to save the day if allowed to play their own special role in reducing flammable vegetation, in building soils, in seed dispersal, in preventing catastrophic, soil-sterilizing fires, etc. They stand ready to counter imbalances brought on by human civilization and its contamination of the atmosphere, much of which is caused by hordes of domestic livestock (de Haan et al. 2006).

Humus and soil building

Equid feces build the humus content of soils to a substantial degree. This humus allows soil to gain more texture and retain more water, which dampens out fires; humus promotes more productive and bio-diverse plant and animal communities. Because their feces are not as thoroughly degraded in the gut as those of ruminant grazers, they contribute more to food chains/webs, e.g., dung beetles to birds and lizards to higher trophic predators such as cats and eagles, etc.

Equine feces aid the watershed by creating damper conditions, because the soil particles to which they reduce (micelles) retain more moisture, i.e., more water adheres to the surface area of these particles. Hence ground water tables are replenished, feeding more seeps and springs more continuously. And upon these springs and seeps, many species of plants and animals depend. Some fire is of benefit to an ecosystem, but fires that over-consume, over-extend, and over-intensify can set the evolution of a terrestrial life community way back and result in a very sterile environment that could take thousands of years of “peace” to recover.

Upper incisors and further insights

Equids possess both upper and lower incisors that permit them to selectively nip pieces of vegetation, such as grass or the leaves of bushes or trees. Major ruminant grazers such as cattle and sheep do not have upper incisors and consequently can and do rip up plants by their roots more frequently with the action of their lower teeth and tongue against their hard upper palates. This often exposes soils to destructive wind and rain erosion, especially when too many of the ruminants are placed upon any given area of land. And wild horses are much more mobile in their daily and seasonal feeding rounds than are cattle.

Brumbies on the Chandler River, in Oxley Wild Rivers National Park. Photo: Cgoodwin, CC BY 3.0 from Wikimedia Commons
Brumbies on the Chandler River, in Oxley Wild Rivers National Park. Photo: Cgoodwin, CC BY 3.0 from Wikimedia Commons

Equids’ relationship to biodiversity

Equid species diversify and strengthen the community they inhabit in a variety of ways when allowed to achieve population stability over time and when not over-imposed upon by humanity. The process of natural selection must be allowed to operate sufficiently long for this to be the case. Then these equids can and do create a greater variety of environmental conditions that make possible a greater variety of niches that can be occupied by the species that are coevolving with them.

Being large, powerful animals, equids can push their way through thickets of brush to form trails. Specifically, they open thick vegetative understories to light and air, and the more diverse exposures resulting from equine activities create conditions intermediary to the extremes of wind, temperature, and various soil conditions. This physically defines a greater variety of niches fillable by a more diverse array of species.

Equids’ relationship to vegetative productivity and natural cycles

When allowed to integrate into wilderness, the individual life histories of wild equids come to reflect natural oscillations, such as annual seasons and more long-term cycles. This they do along with the plants and animals that share their habitat. They harmoniously blend over time. As large animals that eat relatively large quantities and disperse their grazing and browsing activity over broad areas as semi-nomads, equids can become the harvesters and the renewers over vast ecosystems, true to their keystone role.

Their cropping of vegetation, often dry and coarse, reduces the possibility for major, soil-sterilizing fires. This cropping sparks vegetative renewal, the re-budding of new and tender shoots of greater nutritional value, especially to ruminants whose digestive and metabolic systems are over-taxed by the coarse, dry vegetation that equids can better handle. And thus the overall productivity of the land is annually increased, as studies prove (Fahnestock, JT and Detling, JK. 1999 [both]).

Natural self-stabilization of population and reserve design

Wild horses form tight-knit stallion and elder-mare-governed bands. Over time, each band searches out and establishes its own home range, which may cover hundreds of square miles annually in drier regions. The ecological mosaic that results among all such particular band home ranges in a given area prevents over-crowding and overgrazing. Once available habitat is filled, the horse, as a climax species, limits its own population as density-dependent controls are triggered.

In the immediate future, true wild-equid-containing sanctuaries need to be established. Here livestock should be excluded or at least greatly minimized and wild equids allowed to establish viable populations in the thousands of individuals (Duncan 1992). These fairly populated sanctuaries will be viable in the long-term. They will preserve the vigor of the horses and burros they were designed to conserve.

Employing principles of Reserve Design, the following directives will serve as guides in achieving the above goals:

  • Allow each wild equid herd to fully fill its ecological niche space within each given area bounded by natural or where necessary artificial barriers, and by buffer zones. Then allow each specific herd to self-stabilize, or auto-regulate, its population, within this area. Such auto-regulation can happen if we humans allow. Equids are “climax species,” which is to say, members of the “climax successional sere,” or stage, and do not expand out of control to destroy their habitat and ultimately themselves. Each band within a herd population is usually governed by a lead stallion (patron). He watches out for and defends the band and does most of the breeding. A usually older, lead mare also aids in this role. This mare is very wise as to where the best foraging, watering, mineral procurement, sheltering areas, etc., are located. She leads the band along paths uniting these habitat components. These include longer seasonal migratory routes between higher summering and lower wintering habitats. Both patron and lead mare socially inhibit reproduction among younger members of their band. As resources become limiting, physiological and social responses result in decreased reproduction in any given band or herd (Rogovin and Moshkin 2007).
  • Employ natural barriers where possible, or, where such do not exist, semi-permeable, artificial barriers, where necessary, in designing each wild horse sanctuary.
  • Design and employ buffer zones around the wild horse sanctuaries. Here a gradual tapering off of wild horse presence would occur through the implementation of discouragements to their transiting into areas where danger exists for them, such as in farms or cities. This may involve the use of what wildlife managers term “adverse conditioning” as well as “positive reinforcement”.
  • In order to realize healthy, balanced wild-horse-containing ecosystems, as full a complement of plant and animal species should be allowed. Wherever possible, this should include large carnivores/omnivores native to the region in question, such as the dingo. These will provide an additional limitation on wild horse populations (and wild donkey), one that will act through natural selection to make any given population more fit for survival in the wild and more harmoniously adapted to its particular ecosystem.


Bell RHV. The use of the herb layer by grazing ungulates in the Serengeti. In: Watson A ed. Animal Populations in Relation to their Food Source. Oxford, U.K.: Blackwell Science Publications; 1970: 11-125.

Berger J. Wild Horses of the Great Basin: Social Competition and Population Size. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 1986.

De Haan C, Steinfeld H, Rosales, M, Gerber P, Wassenaar T, Castel V. Livestock’s Long Shadow: Environmental Issues and Options. Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture Organziation of the United Nations; 2006. 390.

Downer CC. The horse and burro as positively contributing returned natives in North America. American Journal of Life Sciences. 2014; 2(1): 5-23

Downer CC. The Wild Horse Conspiracy. 2014. 314.

Downer CC. Wild and free-roaming horses and burros of North America: Factual and sensitive statement – how they help the ecosystem. Natural Horse. 2005; 7(3): 10-11.

Downer CC. Overgrazing is by humankind. Bulletin of the Theosophy Science Study Group. 1987.; 25 (5, 6): 57-60.

Downer CC. Proposal for wild horse/burro reserve design as a solution to present crisis. Natural Horse. 2010; 12(5): 26-27.

Duncan P. Zebras, asses, and horses: An action plan for the conservation of wild equids. Gland Switzerland: IUCN Species Survival Commission, Equid Specialist Group; 1992.

Fahnestock JT, Detling JK. The influence of herbivory on plant cover and species composition in the Pryor Mountain Wild Horse Range. Plant Ecology. 1999; 144: 145-157.

Fahnestock JT, Detling JK. Plant responses to defoliation and resource supplementation in the Pryor Mountains. J. Range Management. 1999; 52: 263-270.

Groves CP. Horses, Asses and Zebras in the Wild. London, U.K.: Newton Abbot Publishers; 1974. 192.

MacFadden BJ. Fossil Horses: Systematics, Paleobiology, and Evolution of the Family Equidae. Cambridge, U.K; Cambridge University Press; 1992

Meeker JO. Interactions between Pronghorn Antelope and Feral Horses in Northwestern Nevada. MS thesis in Wildlife Management. Reno, NV: University of Nevada-Reno: 1979.

Moehlman PD (ed). Equids: Zebras, Asses, and Horses: Status Survey and Conservation Action Plan. IUCN/SSC Equid Specialist Group, IUCN (The World Conservation Union). Gland Switzerland: 2005.

Oxley R, CC Downer. Deserts. In: Hare T, ed. Nature Worlds Macmillan Reference. London, U.K.: Duncan Baird Publishers; 1994: 116.

Peck S. Reserve Design. Planning for Biodiversity: Issues and Examples. Washington, DC: Island Press; 1998: 89-114.

Ricklefs RE. Ecology, 2nd Edition. New York: Chiron Press; 1979. 51-65.

Rogovin KA, Moshkin MP. [Autoregulation in mammalian populations and stress: an old theme revisited]. Zhurnal Obshchei biologii. 2007; 68(4): 244-267 (in Russian).

University of Wyoming. Proceedings of the Symposium on the Ecology and Behavior of Wild and Feral Equids. 1979; Laramie WY; Sept. 6-8, 1974. 236.

Williams AR. Horse Power. National Geographic. 2012: 25. Note: This article tells how horses are being used to restore degraded ecosystems in many countries of the world.

Zimov SA. Pleistocene park: return of the mammoths’ ecosystem. Science. 2005; 308: 796-798.

• Receive a notification when a new article is posted:

18 thoughts on “Brumbies can fill a useful role in Australian ecosystems, says ecologist

  • June 5, 2018 at 6:55 am

    Thanks for publishing the essay that went with my poster presented to the Ecological Society of Australia annual conference in Alice Springs back in October 2014. I went on to visit many places where brumbies occur in Australia as well as many where they do not occur, and weighing all the great diversity of this vast ecosystem including its diverse people, it does not strike me that the wild horses are the “big destroyers” some people like to say they are. To me this smacks of tunnel-vision and scapegoating, though I am certainly for preserving the native fauna and flora. What people need to recognize is that there is a need to see the life community as ever evolving and adapting. I think the most critical challenge humans face today is in bringing themselves to allow all the diverse plants and animals to establish their own sane balance according to true principles that operate in the natural world, and to respect these and learn to live in harmony therewith.

  • June 6, 2018 at 1:00 pm

    Thank you for your modern and dynamic style of reasoning. Unfortunately not something that any of our Politicians or their so called ‘scientists’ have!

  • June 6, 2018 at 3:31 pm

    An ‘in-depth scientific’ approach to our ecology, inclusive of all the natural and purpose-designed participants in it’s health – a fine balance that mankind would do well to take note of and observe respectfully. The Planet’s health and mankind’s future depend on it.

  • June 6, 2018 at 9:46 pm

    Where is the methodology to support these claims for the Australian landscape? Where is the actual on the ground monitoring of the effects of horse activities compared to areas where horses aren’t found? Counts of flora and fauna species in areas with horses compared to areas where they aren’t? Water testing and species diversity and numbers around horse affected waterholes? Reference to papers that do show negative impacts in similar types of landscapes such as the well documented negative effects of horses in the Kaimanawa ranges of NZ as well as the findings of monitoring projects in the Alpine National Park undertaken by the Victorian NPWS?

    Unlike the US which had horses until the last ice age and then only a short (in evolutionary time) period without them before they were re-introduced, as well as large herds of other native hard hooved animals such as bison and deer, Australia has no history of co-evolution with such animals throughout its history. The ecosystems reviewed by Downer in this article are of arid zones in the US. These may share some similarities to central Australian ecosystems, but are completely unlike the wet temperate areas such as the Snowy Mountains, Blue Mountains and wet temperate forests of Queensland. Thus to claim that effects observed in arid zones apply to wet temperate and alpine areas can’t be substantiated. In fact, a recent study by the University of Queensland investigating the effect of different landscape types on feral horse hooves showed that horses in arid zones had very different hoof morphology compared to horses living in the Carnarvon area, a wet forest ecosystem and that conclusions about an ideal hoof conformation had to take into account the environment in which the horse lived. Likewise, the behaviour of horses in the arid zone was significantly different to the horses in the wet forest due to the differences in access to water, feed and temperature.

    Australia has many diverse and unique ecosystems, none of which co-evolved with horses. We have the unenviable record of the highest number of mammalian extinctions in the past 200 years and we will be on track to that if we continue to care more about wild horses than our ancient, fragile landscapes and their endangered animals found no-where else in the world.

    It is estimated that Australia has the largest population of feral horses anywhere in the world with an estimate of 500,000 across the country. They are in no way endangered and multiple genetic testing efforts have shown there is nothing unique about their DNA. They are simply domestic horses that have either been deliberately abandoned or escaped. Australian horse owners also send between 40,000 and 90,000 of their own horses to slaughter in knackeries and abattoirs every year without the handwringing or romanticising. Attend any local auction and there are plenty of ordinary people willing to chance their unwanted horses to the meat buyers.

    It is not just horses that negatively impact Australian ecosystems- cats, foxes, pigs, camels, donkeys, deer, rabbits and humans have all had a terrible impact. Hundreds of millions of our money gets spent on trying to control the animals and reduce their impacts. It seems its only the horses that we have a collective blindspot about.

    • May 21, 2020 at 1:28 am

      How much wildlife does the 1080 bait kill in the Alpine Region that Vic Parks aerial drop? Horses have been in this region for over 200 years and as an equestrian nation any horse property owner will tell you the damage they are accused of is nigh impossible. They eco system try help to create is beneficial and to suddenly remove them as they tried to several days ago would have a great negative impact.

      • July 23, 2020 at 11:16 am

        Firstly regarding 1080. This poison naturally occurs in the Australian environment. Native animals and birds have developed a tolerance to it. It has been laid in my area and we have thriving populations of meat eating birds. Now regarding your experience. Horses have not been in the area for over 200 years and in any case that is such a small amount of time compared to how long many other species which the horses threaten have been there. I cannot see you as a person who has ever visited the affected areas to view the damage yourself. Maybe you do not live in a wet area but I do and my horses do terrible damage to the ground during winter. The Bogong High Plains has wet areas all year round but these are threatened by horses. The bogs are critical for stream flow in summer and take more than my lifetime to repair. I am sure you are a good horse person but you lack any credibility to discuss matters concerning fragile Alpine environments.

  • May 20, 2020 at 4:14 am

    Thanks for commenting, K.Brown. While I appreciate your bringing added perspective to this issue, I think you fail to appreciate my point concerning how all the various species can establish a healthy balance among themselves that will be conducive to a more steady-state equilibrium over time. Remember the Earth’s long-term history has experienced some real major and abrupt changes yet always managed to recover though often with a somewhat different cast of species. The roles these species play, however, remain remarkably the same. Humans need to respect all living creatures and the natural balance they can and do achieve if so allowed. Then they need to learn how to harmoniously fit in with this balance, not be continuously upsetting it!

    • May 21, 2020 at 1:41 am

      Thank you so much Craig.
      Three days ago shooters were on the ground, in the middle of the night at Nunniong Victoria ready to eradicate approx 200 heritage horses and where we had over 100 supporters throughout the Park. I posted your article to the Facebook page Rural Resistance and administrator Phillip Maguire because it is the only sensible acknowledgement for the Waler Heritage War Horses and it received such a positive response. Phil was able to obtain an injunction at the 11th hour and the cull was called off…He returns to court on 25th May and we are all extremely concerned of what the outcome may be. Is there anything in the way of support and/or supportive documentation you may be willing and able to send to him.
      We feel the outcome of this court case could be a catalyst for what happens in our other states around Australia with our Heritage Horses.
      Thank you again Craig for the wonderful article.
      Kindest Regards

      • July 2, 2020 at 3:31 pm

        Sorry for the late reply, Nicola. I see the fight goes on and I will be on a webinar this evening (Australian time) and have posed questions bring up some of the major points of my article to Dr. Don Driscoll, who will be the main supporter. I hope I will also be given the opportunity to speak at the end of his talk, at least to make a few points. Must wake up very early here to make this but have been resting today. So glad my article of two years ago helped the brumbies. They are a remarkable heritage and highly evolved companions here on Earth and deserve much more respect. Did you see my more recent article from June 10, 2020?

    • July 2, 2020 at 3:27 pm

      I would also like to add that the wave of major extinctions before that now being caused by our species and that occurred at the close of the Pleistocene really wiped out the Megaherbivores in the continents of the Earth including in Australia. It can be argued that the horses refill the Megaherbivore roles in the ecosystem including that of seed dispersers.

  • May 21, 2020 at 1:49 am

    Australia has a fauna and flora which has a nigh level of endemism, occurring nowhere else in the world. I believe that we have a responsibility -scientific, moral and emotional, to protect our species, or those which we have not already losti. The high level of extinction that has occurred so far has had many causes, but a major one is habitat destruction. We do not have any native hard hoofed ruminants, or non rimunants. Your long discourse on the benefits that horses may provide to the “productivity” etc of the environment, has no relevance to an ecosystem which has got along very well for Millenia, until the introduction of many novel fauna, and plant, species in the last 250 years. I find the suggestion that horses should be allowed to establish wild, self-sustaining populations in our small areas of alpine country, so that they can “improve the productivity ” regardless of the threat they present to the native plants and animals of the region, and the ecosystem services it provides, as ludicrous
    and offensive. We value our native heritage and wild horses are not part of it.

    • June 1, 2020 at 9:25 pm

      J Frankenberg – millions of ‘native plants and animals’ died during the 2019/2020 bushfire catastrophe due to NPWS inability to manage our wildlife reserves in a manner that Indigenous Australians have had to learn after hunting to extinction the Megafauna herbivores who had an important part to play in mitigating fire risk with their grazing habits. The great myth that Australia has never had ‘hooved’ animals needs to be buried along with all outdated militant ecology models. Paleontology has revealed the existence of a hooved giant kangaroo – Please educate yourself with the latest science and be part of the solution that will help protect Australia from another inferno like we just experienced. Read up on the success of rewilding in Europe. Keeping large herbivores out of Australian wilderness areas is signing a death sentence to all species (whether they be native or introduced). As always Australia is late to leverage the scientific insights of other nations and comments like yours reflect this lag.

      • July 2, 2020 at 3:36 pm

        Yes, Syvianne, and in late reply to M. Frankenberg, the naturally living horses in Australia have a major beneficial role as catastrophic wildfire mitigators and preventers. Consequently, their wholesale removal can boomerang in allowing even more serious and devastating wildfires. Also we should contemplate how the horses can adapt and come to live harmoniously with the more deeply native fauna and flora of Australia. This is possible and should not be overlooked.

  • July 3, 2020 at 1:03 pm

    This debate is becoming somewhat ridiculous, with the suggestion that the presence or absence of horses could have had anything to do with last summer’s fires, which were driven by climatic effects driven by climate change. I am concerned about the alpine ecosystems that are being destroyed by large horse populations. The sphagnum bogs are a very important part of the hydrological conditions that moderate flows into our major river systems. Horses are destroying areas that have only gradually started recovering from the damage caused over the last century by cattle grazing. Horses will not “adapt” so that this will no longer happen.
    I understand that some horse lovers want to put the the romantic notion of populations of horses living wild above concern for the survival of native plants and animals that occur nowhere else. But don’t try to justify this with peru do science that is mostly wishful thinking.

  • July 22, 2020 at 9:39 am

    Interesting article Craig but even a lay person can see you have no understanding of Australian conditions. The advocates for saving these horses are science deniers but will cherry pick science when it appears to suit their cause. Your article mentions a number of seemingly positive things attributed to horses and the negative aspect of those are not mentioned by you. We are looking to remove horses from sensitive and fragile Alpine environments which do not have ruminant grazing. Weeds were introduced to these environments and horses have the ability to spread those weeds. One weed which would impact all of our grazing land is Hawk weed. Horses are spreading a fungus which is killing frogs in the streams. Contaminated soil impacts in their hooves and is transferred to other places. You mention ‘A little-recognized fact is that the wallowing habit’ which is denied by the pro horse activists and attributed only to deer. You also say ‘Wild horses also locate water seeps through their keen sense of smell and enlarge these through pawing’ which is what they do to the delicate peat bogs which hold 30 times their weight in water. You make mention of the hard hoof and the hammer like action impacting of the soil when Australia has not evolved to deal with hard hoofed animals and this pugging and pawing is destroying stream banks and riparian areas. Your benefit is to help seeds germinate but you forget Australia plants do not require this. Then you make a totally unsubstantiated and false claim the horses will reduce the intensity of bushfires because of their grazing habits. Fuel load in Australia comes from trees and shrubs, not grass. Trees drop branches and bark which builds up on the forest floor. All of the things horses do not eat contribute to bushfire intensity. I watched the fires burn this last season and when it got to the grassland it slowed. I was on the fire line. Areas were feral horses are plentiful were devastated by fires and the horse’s presence made no difference. You talk about arid areas and say horses are well adapted to these places but then mention snow in the next breath as if it that is a part of the Australia arid landscape.

    Clearly you have no idea of Australian conditions or ecology and your claims will now be jumped on by those who also have little understanding and only seek some justification for not ridding the land of a feral pest for which they have some emotional attachment to. I doubt any reputable scientific person in this country would consider anything you have put forward as valid or applicable to Australia.

  • July 27, 2020 at 1:50 pm

    Fascinating article which I came across by chance/luck on unrelated Google search! Also the comments are equally as fascinating and informative. Firstly, in no way shape or form am I an expert (or a horse owner for that matter), therefore I have no bias for or against a wild horse population. However, for what it’s worth I did sit next to an Australian farmer from QLD on a plane who commented that the restrictions on Free Grazing in bushland and permits for seasonal burning had become insanely difficult the past few years. So much so that farmers had stopped both burning & free grazing cattle, which (according to him) had allowed the fuel to build up over time resulting in the mother of all bush fires. Also (and this is my 80’s/90’s education talking) I was under the impression that Australia never had hooved animals, therefore species such as Wild Buffalo, cattle etc were very destructive; I’d be very interested to hear arguments for/against both of those topics. Once again I’m unsure which of the fence that I belong to, but I am interested in the perspective of both sides and their data to back it up. Regards.

    • February 13, 2021 at 8:40 am

      I live in the Vic High Country among the cattlemen and they have this slogan ‘Alpine grazing reduces blazing’. It is a fraud. When the cattle spent summers on the mountain the cattlemen left their paddocks back home to grow so the cattle had winter feed. If they were concerned about a huge fuel load then why did they not do something about it right next to their homes? You listen to a farmer and they will tell you their view which is based on an economic consequence. It has no basis in fact. Fires start in the mountains due to lightning and burn in areas where access is difficult. Horses and cattle would not graze there anyway. Fires have burnt through the mountains while cattle grazed. Craig Downer’s arguments also have little basis in fact. Horses spread weeds and there is a significant problem in the mountains with Hawkweed and if that gets to the private land then the farmers will suffer economically also. Any benefit horses bring to the environment is significantly outweighed by the detrimental effects.

  • July 21, 2021 at 8:31 am

    I am for the protection of pristine habitats in the Alpine regions and anywhere else in Australia and have proposed triangular, pole-and-rail fences to limit horses from entering these areas. However, I think it is an extreme view that discounts the benign role that horses can and do plan in ecosystems, including in Australia. This concerns how they can adapt along with all the other species to restore a well-functioning ecosystem. This may not be the exact original that occurred before the European colonization of Australia, but I believe it would incorporate many of the original species as well as others that have managed to find their niche in the evolving and adapting ecosystem. We people need to be less draconian in our approach and attitude toward the Great Rest of Life and stop making knee-jerk, reactive responses to the world of Nature. The horse species is an ancient presence on Earth and its finding a survival capacity in Australia should tell the thoughtful human something important about its belonging. Charles Darwin wisely pointed to the “struggle to survive” among all living creatures, and I would like to add that mutual adaptation to many other species is a vital part of this vital and ongoing process.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *