The findings of a groundbreaking Canadian study that examined racing deaths suggest that characteristic differences across three breeds might be a factor in track-related deaths.
The study team say their research into track deaths involving Thoroughbreds, Standardbreds and Quarter Horses has provided deeper insights into strategies that could reduce mortality and improve welfare.
University of Guelph Professor Peter Physick-Sheard and a team of researchers examined 1713 cases of racehorse deaths from 2003 to 2015, focusing on track-related fatalities.
“The study reveals parallels between mortality and the intensity of the overall management of the horses, their lifestyle and the type of work they do,” said Physick-Sheard, who is in the Department of Population Medicine.
“Training and racing at top speed within a short amount of time and space is a health risk for horses, as it would be for any other species, including humans.”
Most racing in North America involves intense exertion over a relatively short distance, he added.
The study, published in the Equine Veterinary Journal, is the first to compare mortality in three racing breeds, and represents the most complete data set on the issue so far.
The researchers analyzed race and trial run data from the Ontario horse racing industry. A provincial registry of racehorse mortality requires mandatory reporting of all deaths occurring within 60 days of a race or trial run.
“The industry is committed to using scientific research to mitigate health risks to animals,” said Physick-Sheard, “and this new research definitely holds insights that will help in that effort.”.
His study aimed to characterize and quantify exercise-associated mortality in racehorses and identify breed differences.
Physick-Sheard said breed differences provide deeper insights into strategies that could reduce mortality, improve the welfare of racehorses and reduce the costs of participation in the sport.
He found that Thoroughbreds had the highest exercise-associated mortality rate and risk. Out of every 1000 races, 2.27 deaths were exercise-associated. About 1 percent of racing Thoroughbreds die annually in association with racing or trial runs.
The mortality rate and risk were lowest for Standardbreds, at 0.28 deaths per 1000 race starts, and an annual death rate of 0.23 to 0.24 per cent. This breed is given more extensive training preparation and racing, Physick-Sheard said.
Mortality related to high-intensity exercise in Quarter Horses was 1.49 deaths per 1000 race starts, with an annual death rate of 0.60 to 0.69 per cent from the activity.
For all breeds, musculoskeletal injury was the major contributing cause of mortality.
Thoroughbreds and Quarter Horses also succumbed to dying suddenly and accidents.
“The industry has characteristics revealed by this data that point at mechanisms that could be used to significantly reduce mortality,” Physick-Sheard said.
“You can use carefully targeted strategies to reduce risk and increase the safety of the sport, something to which the Ontario and the global racing industries are devoting a lot of time and energy.”
The study revealed that the sex of standardbreds strongly affects mortality risk, with young stallions at higher risk than mares or geldings. Among older horses, geldings have higher risk than males.
Thoroughbred stallions face a higher risk than Standardbred stallions.
Training strategies could be modified to address the animal welfare and economic implications, Physick-Sheard said.
“It is possible that the very behavioural attributes traditionally seen as conferring a competitive advantage may have an overall negative impact.”
The findings allow the industry to monitor and assess changes in management and racing practices, he said.
Structural factors within the horseracing industry can be addressed through rule changes, knowledge and education, Physick-Sheard added.
But the characteristics of the individual horse breeds also play a significant role in mortality risks and need to be considered.
“We’re starting to focus more on the things that are potentially inherent to the breeds of horse, as opposed to characteristics of the work they perform,” Physick-Sheard said.
“As we get more insight into those horse factors, we become more aware of other influences that are possible causes of increased mortality risk.”