Whiplash: Why the injury that keeps on giving can’t be seen

© Mike Bain

Whiplash symptoms that last years after an accident but cannot be seen in tests could be down to previously unseen functional changes in the pain and posture processing parts of the brain, according to European research.

The results of the study, published in EBioMedicine, suggest close interaction between the neck and brain, resulting in changes in blood flow.

The authors of the study, from the University of Groningen in the Netherlands and Offenburg University in Germany, say their findings may bring closer the possibility of diagnosing chronic whiplash associated disorder (cWAD), potentially helping relieve people’s pain.

An estimated 3 in 1000 people suffer from whiplash, and one in four of them have chronic symptoms. Whiplash can affect horse riders in a fall but is most often associated with having an accident in a car, when the driver’s neck moves forward and backwards like a whip. Usually these accidents occur at low speed; most people don’t see a doctor as they don’t think anything is wrong. But soon after the accident, they may start noticing pain in their head, neck and jaw. This family of symptoms is called whiplash-associated disorder, and it is notoriously difficult to diagnose.

“Patients often report these symptoms for years, but if they do see a doctor nothing shows up on the tests,” said Dr David Vállez García, lead author of the study.

“Many people start thinking they may be making the symptoms up or trying to make a claim for compensation. It’s a tricky situation in which the patient is in pain, the doctors can’t explain it and people think they’re making it up. We wanted to uncover a real cause of the symptoms – one that could help doctors diagnose and treat it.”

© Mike Bain

Previous research has shown that people with cWAD can be more sensitive to pain, through an effect called central hyperexcitability. Studies have also shown changes in the blood flow in the brain, but none had looked at the two together, to determine whether the connection between the neck and deeper parts of the brain was causing whiplash symptoms.

The researchers scanned the brains of 20 women – 8 healthy, pain-free women and 12 with cWAD – using a technique called positron emission tomography (PET). They exposed each group to four different levels of non-painful electrical neck stimulation and scanned them.

The results showed changes in the blood flow in areas of the brain involved in pain perception and processing sensory information from within the body (interoceptive stimuli). These changes, say the researchers, could be down to a mismatch in the way interoceptive stimuli are integrated in pain processing regions.

“With the recent accumulated scientific evidence, we can now say there is something happening in the brain,” said Dr. Vállez García. “I think our study will improve awareness about the disease, of the public and of medical doctors, and help people with chronic whiplash-associated disorders get the decent treatment they need.”

The research goes a long way to explaining why sufferers of cWAD can experience chronic symptoms, but more research is needed to understand in detail the role of the brain in this process. Dr. Vállez García and the team are now considering what to look at next, such as inflammation in the brain or changes in the structure of other functional regions.

Altered Regional Cerebral Blood Flow in Chronic Whiplash Associated Disorders, by David Vállez García, Janine Doorduin, Antoon T.M. Willemsen Rudi A.J.O. Dierckx, Andreas Otte (http://dx.doi.org10.1016/j.ebiom.2016.07.008). EBioMedicine, volume 10 (2016), published by Elsevier.

One thought on “Whiplash: Why the injury that keeps on giving can’t be seen

  • August 8, 2019 at 8:03 pm

    I have chronic whip lash from a fall 2yrs ago. I have Arthrosis in my c1,c2,c3,c4 and my neck compresses on the right vein which slows blood flow to and from the brain causing migraines. I have been trying to get help for 1yr now, as I cannot ride my horses at more than a very slow walk, which is very hard as I have TBs and love dressage. Any help would be appreciated.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *