Death by a thousand cuts in equestrian sport


stock-eye_1179It’s summer in the southern hemisphere – the season for sand and sandals. In horse sport, it seems to be the season for sand and scandals.

Yes, we’re living the dream. Or is it a nighmare? Followers of horse sport will be well aware of the endurance troubles in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) that hit the headlines this past month.

We now have a new deal and, who knows, maybe the dust will finally settle around UAE endurance and the FEI can return to happy families.

It is now a matter of waiting to see if the new measures will make any significant difference, which provides a nice window to look at the issue of reputational damage to horse sport.

Scandals are never far away in any number of sports, it would seem. And the damage can be very real.

Take cycling, for example, where Lance Armstrong turned the Tour de France into the Tour de Farce. The doping stories that emerged in that sport have done terrible harm to cycling’s reputation. I, for one, struggle to take the sport seriously any more.

Doping has been a blight on many sports, especially so athletics in recent times.

To this day, there are world records from the 1970s that still stand, with marks that modern “clean” athletes have been unable to get near. I guess, if nothing else, it shows that officialdom can stay ahead of the drug cheats to some degree at least.

And then we have match-fixing. A whole host of professional sports have been embroiled in match-fixing allegations. Cricket, tennis, you name it.

When we read about doping in athletics, our opinion of the sport is diminished. When we learn about match-fixing in cricket, we begin to wonder when we see curious quirks during the game.

Followers of horse sport tend to take scandals within its disciplines personally, because they are well aware that the horse is not choosing to compete. It is not a case of an athlete abusing their own body. So, if horses are seen to be pushed too hard, or suffer nasty mishaps, we react.

It is illustrative to look at other sports, because it gives us some insight into what “outsiders” might think of our sport when they read about welfare problems in endurance, hyperflexion in dressage, racehorses being whipped, or steeplechasers tumbling over fences.

Scandals really do cause damage.

The world has moved on a great deal since I started in journalism, with an Olivetti Lettera 22 manual typewriter in front of me. Back then, Social Media would have been a great name for a rock band, but little else.

Today, it has more power than traditional media in many ways. It can get things done. It can provide feedback in seconds, even if it isn’t necessarily welcome. It can be cruel and kind, sometimes all at once.

What worries me at the moment is the inability of horse sport administrators to be able to effectively deal with these problems and move on.

The UAE problems have been like a death by a thousand cuts for endurance. It is the crisis that just keeps on giving.

How could the scenes we saw in the closing stages of the junior and young riders’ race at Al Wathba on January 30, which caused such a storm in social media, have been allowed to happen following the agreement signed between the FEI and the Emirates Equestrian Federation last year?

Who was to blame? The riders? The trainers? The endurance stables? The organising committee? The Emirates Equestrian Federation? The FEI?

On this particular issue, I think the perceived need for diplomacy in the last 18 months has trumped the need for meaningful action – or meaningful enforcement.

So, a few days ago we learned of the 12 new measures aimed at sorting out UAE endurance once and for all.

FEI secretary general Sabrina Ibáñez said after the agreement was announced: “We need to change hearts as well as minds, and the solution lies in education and dialogue, as well as taking a tough line with sanctions.”

I am sure that Ibáñez is right, yet 11 of the 12 measures amount to changes to rules and procedures. The only change that could even remotely touch on the “hearts and minds” of riders is their required attendance at a ride briefing. But even that is a stretch.

So, here’s the final question as we write another chapter in this long-running saga: Have we seen the last of the damaging headlines that have plagued endurance?

If not, I think it is fair to say that our horse sport administrators are not a quick study.

5 thoughts on “Death by a thousand cuts in equestrian sport

  • February 19, 2016 at 12:19 am

    It hasn’t slowed them down. In today’s ‘race’, the GAMILATI ENDURANCE CUP FOR MARES – CEN 120 KM, the winner did the last lap at 32.11 kph and the 3rd place getter at 37.3kph!

    Those speeds are potential horse killers. Only a matter of time.

  • February 20, 2016 at 7:45 am

    Nothing has changed. We have had two CEN 120 KM rides in Dubai over the last two days and the speeds seem to be getting worse instead of better. A horse who was placed 2nd in a CEI3* 160 KM in Dubai last January and then, a month later, was placed 1st in another CEI3* 160KM in Abu Dhabi only managed one loop today before being eliminated due to Metabolic issues at Gate 1 with a heart rate of 83. I do not know the fate of this horse but the killing fields of the UAE seem to be open for business as usual.

  • February 20, 2016 at 9:34 am

    I want to believe these measures will help but I don’t think they will. Yesterday another desert race was held. The Al Khawaneej Ride For Junior & Young Riders 120km ride. The first five horses completed the final loop at speeds of 33 to 35.5 kph. The loop where the heartrate criteria was lowered. Surprisingly all of these five horses met the HR requirements. Amazing horses and a real credit to the Arabian breed that they are able to race like this and still have a heart that recovers at the required point in time to the necessary heart rate…. Amazing. But can they all do this and can they do it time and time again?

    Have we seen the last of the damaging headlines that have plagued endurance? Unless Sheikh Sultan’s reforms are taken on board by all in the Middle East and the speeds are reduced…I think not.

  • February 20, 2016 at 10:06 am

    To talk of ’changing hearts and minds’ is ingenuous. The culture doesn’t allow for anything so benevolent. When the dust settles we will know that the FEI has capitulated and life for the horses in the UAE has resumed as before.

    To answer your question – no, we haven’t seen the last of the damaging headlines that plague endurance. Unfortunately our horse sport admins DO seem to be slow on the uptake – we have waited in vain for a purposeful statement from ESNZ, something that would give the ‘grassroots’ riders confidence that the Endurance Board hold to the precepts of horse welfare that are at the core of endurance riding and in the absence of which we are seeing a drastic drop in the numbers of entries, nationally.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.