Equine family tree needs a trim, say scientists

Bones of a new species of the hippidion horse, discovered in South America.
Bones of a new species of the hippidion horse, discovered in South America.

The horse’s family tree should be restructured, according to an international team of scientists.Ancient DNA recovered from extinct horse species from around the world has challenged the fossil record of the horse family.

Only the modern horse, zebras, wild asses and donkey survive today, but many other lineages have become extinct over the last 50,000 years.

Before the advent of DNA analysis, fossils were grouped according to their morphological characteristics.

Now analysis of DNA fragments isolated from ancient bones has prompted scientists to reassess the relationships between some of the ancient and modern members of the horse family.

The study involved an international team of researchers.

They examined 35 equid fossils from around the world (South America, Europe, Southwest Asia, and South Africa). Ancient mitochondrial DNA (aDNA) was identified in 22 of the specimens.

The aDNA samples were extracted, amplified, and sequenced in specialist laboratories in Lyon and Adelaide.

Professor Alan Cooper, director of the Australian Centre for Ancient DNA, based at the University of Adelaide, says despite an excellent fossil record of the Equidae, there are still many gaps in our evolutionary knowledge.

“Our results change both the basic picture of recent equid evolution, and ideas about the number and nature of extinct species,” he said.

The study used bones from caves to identify new horse species in Eurasia and South America. It also revealed that the Cape zebra, an extinct giant species from South Africa, was simply a large variant of the modern Plains zebra.

The Cape zebra weighed up to 400 kilograms and stood up to 150 centimetres at the shoulder blades.

“The Plains zebra group once included the famous extinct quagga, so our results confirm that this group was highly variable in both coat colour and size.”

Dr. Ludovic Orlando and right professor Eske Willerslev.
Dr. Ludovic Orlando, pictured at left with professor Eske Willerslev. The pair made headlines in June 2013 after mapping the genome of a 700,000 year-old horse. © Uffe Wilken

Lead author of the paper, Dr Ludovic Orlando, from Ecole Normale Supérieure, of Lyon, says the group discovered a new species of the distinct, small hippidion horse in South America.

“Previous fossil records suggested this group was part of an ancient lineage from North America but the DNA showed these unusual forms were part of the modern radiation of equid species,” Dr Orlando says.

A new species of ass was also detected on the Russian Plains and appears to be related to European fossils dating back more than 1.5 million years. Carbon dates on the bones reveal that this species was alive as recently as 50,000 years ago.

“Overall, the new genetic results suggest that we have underestimated how much a single species can vary over time and space, and mistakenly assumed more diversity among extinct species of megafauna,” Professor Cooper says.

“This has important implications for our understanding of human evolution, where a large number of species are currently recognised from a relatively fragmentary fossil record.

“It also implies that the loss of species diversity that occurred during the megafaunal extinctions at the end of the last Ice Age may not have been as extensive as previously thought.

“In contrast, ancient DNA studies have revealed that the loss of genetic diversity in many surviving species appears to have been extremely severe,” Professor Cooper says. “This has serious implications for biodiversity and the future impacts of climate change.”


The study was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
PNAS December 22, 2009 vol. 106 no. 51 21754-21759
Published online 27.12.09.

Article first published on Horsetalk.co.nz on December 29, 2009.


Latest research and information from the horse world.

3 thoughts on “Equine family tree needs a trim, say scientists

  • September 23, 2013 at 9:32 am

    Excellent and all the more reason to preserve the wild horses and burros as viably sized, ecologically well adapted populations here in North America, their evolutionary cradle!

    • February 3, 2014 at 1:42 pm

      Yes just like all hominid bipedals came from africa ! Bollocks !!!

  • March 24, 2014 at 6:42 am

    I appears we need these grazers help prevent fires and to re-seed the grasses.
    They are a vital part of history our health and our land/county.

    Tell me why others want them gone? It seems we don’t know we have until it gone. I hope human being don’t shot themselves in the foot.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *