Genetic sleuths unravel historic Derby mystery

Bend Or
Bend Or

Genetic research has unmasked the truth in a 132-year-old Epsom Derby mystery, as thoroughbreds line up this weekend for the British classic. 

In 1880 the identity of the winner of the Epsom Derby – the classic race run this Saturday – was famously disputed in a squabble worthy of a Dick Francis novel.

Now, analysis of DNA has solved the mystery conclusively – and has also confirmed the authenticity of the skeleton of one of the most famous stallions of all time.

A team of researchers examining DNA extracted from the skeletons of historic horses in order to throw light on the origin of diseases found in modern horses have, in the course of their work, solved some of the mysteries that have long puzzled the horse-racing world.

Their meticulous analysis answers the question of which of two horses actually won the Epsom Derby of 1880, revealing that the winner was running under the name of another horse.

The same study has also led to the authentication of the 220-year-old skeleton of Eclipse, a legendary name in racing worldwide.

The research, published in the current issue of the journal Archaeometry, involved laboratory work to analyse the DNA contained in bones, hair and blood of 300 living thoroughbreds, plus an examination of historic archives and iconic paintings.

Genetic history

The research project was led jointly by Dr Mim Bower of the University of Cambridge, who is an expert in the domestication of horses in pre-history, and a team from the Royal Veterinary College.

“The purpose of the research was to develop tools that will help us understand the genetic history of the Thoroughbred horse – and, in particular, to discover when certain catastrophic genetic diseases might have entered the gene pool,” said Dr Bower.

“Knowledge of the history of these diseases will help us in improving the health of living racehorses.”

In the Epsom Derby of June 1880, a horse named Bend Or crossed the finishing line just ahead of his rival, Robert the Devil.

Celebrations turned sour when the owners of Robert the Devil claimed that Bend Or was running under the wrong name and was in fact a horse called Tadcaster. They argued that the two had been confused as yearlings – and that Robert the Devil was therefore the bona fide winner.

Bend Or and Tadcaster came from the Duke of Westminster’s Eaton Stud in Cheshire. With the same sire but out of two different dams, the three-year-olds looked strikingly similar – though the dam of the horse running in the Derby as Bend Or came from a lineage that had never won a race and the dam of the horse known as Tadcaster came from a winning line.

Stable switch

At a stewards’ inquiry the owners of the two horses, who had long been arch enemies,  argued their cases. The inquiry found for the owners of Bend Or who went on to stand at stud and, on the basis of his Derby win, made the Duke of Westminster a small fortune.

One of the stud grooms who had handled the two horses as youngsters was reported to have confessed on his deathbed that the two animals had been confused, but he had been dismissed by the Duke of Westminster so his word was doubted.

Samples of DNA taken from the skeleton of Bend Or, which is archived in the Natural History Museum, were shown to match that of the living relatives of Tadcaster, proving almost without doubt that the horse running under the name Bend Or in the Derby of 1880 was indeed Tadcaster.

Eclipse's skeleton is now on display at the Royal Veterinary College, near Hatfield. (Credit: Copyright Royal Veterinary College 2006)
Eclipse's skeleton is on display at the Royal Veterinary College, near Hatfield. © Royal Veterinary College

Total Eclipse

The same team of researchers have also looked at the DNA of Eclipse, a chestnut stallion named after the solar eclipse of 1 April 1764, during which he was foaled.

Bred by the Duke of Cumberland (known as the Butcher of Culloden), he easily won all 18 of the races in which he was entered, inspiring the phrase “Eclipse first, the rest nowhere”.

Once retired from racing, Eclipse became a phenomenal success at stud, siring more than 300 winners. Some 95 per cent of modern thoroughbreds have him in their ancestry.

“His descendants include Desert Orchid, Shergar, Red Rum, Phar Lap and Northern Dancer to name just a few,” said Dr Bower.

The racing world was keen to discover the secret of Eclipse’s awesome speed and on his death in 1789 an autopsy took place. Performed by a French veterinary surgeon called Vial de Saint Bel and thought to have been the first-ever formally documented animal autopsy in the UK, the procedure revealed that Eclipse had a massive heart – at least 25 per cent larger than average. His large heart, combined with a physique that gave his paces tremendous scope, is thought to be the reason for his outstanding speed on the racecourse.

First autopsy

During the autopsy detailed drawings were made of Eclipse’s physiology and measurements of his bones were noted.

Vial’s autopsy led to the foundation of the London Veterinary College (now The Royal Veterinary College).

Dr Bower said: “The records of this early autopsy represent a vital historical resource for pedigree research which we use to trace the spread of desirable or undesirable genetic traits, for example. Today, the identity and parentage of every thoroughbred horse is verified by genetic typing. In the past, records relied on the accuracy of recording at each of the thoroughbred foundation studs.

“However, our research has shown that early Stud Book records are considerably more accurate than previously thought, and that errors, where they exist, are as a result of a lack of understanding of the precise biological modes of inheritance in the past.

“For example, fraternal sisters being recorded as part of the same maternal lineage, despite sharing a father rather than a mother.”

Eclipse’s skeleton was put on display as a curiosity and later transported up and down Britain, packed into boxes and reassembled at different destinations. It was eventually acquired by the Royal Veterinary College, where it is now on display in its resource centre, known as the Eclipse Building.

No bones about it

It has always been thought that the skeleton of Eclipse, if authentic at all, was likely to have been a composite of bones from different horses including some from the famous stallion himself – and it did seem highly possible that over the years the bones had been confused.

Rumour had it that the head, in particular, came from a different horse. The existence of five “Eclipse” hooves added to scepticism about the skeleton.

Now evidence from meticulous ancient DNA analysis, and cross referencing scientific findings with contemporary sources, indicate that the majority of the skeleton (including the head) is authentic.

The authentication of the bones involved several strands of research which were undertaken in the laboratories at the McDonald Institute in Cambridge and at the Royal Veterinary College in London.

“We matched the mitochondrial DNA taken from Eclipse’s skeleton with DNA taken from his direct female descendants, traced by referencing their lineage from the records contained in the volumes of the Stud Book, early historic studbooks and Bobinsky’s Thoroughbred breed tables, held in Cambridge University Library,” said Dr Bower.

“We also matched the coat colour genes with the colours in Stubbs’s paintings. We looked at the stable isotopes across different elements of the Eclipse skeleton and matched high precision measurements of the skeleton with those taken at the time of the autopsy in 1789. The comparison of measurements was a real puzzle because the inch – which in England was based on three barley grains lying end to end – was not formally standardised until 1959.”

The future

The research that led to these discoveries has implications both for archaeo-geneticists and for veterinarians.

In the early, days racing took place over long distances, typically four miles, with horses being tested for stamina as well as speed.

Races were head to head with just two horses being run against each other, in multiple heats.

The end of the 19th century saw the number of runners being increased and race distances being dramatically shortened.

Short bursts of intense speed put a strain on a horse’s body, with some horses beginning their racing careers at the age of two.

“Thoroughbred horses are elite athletes capable of impressive performances – but they are also prone to debilitating conditions such as bone fracture and tendon injury and exercise induced pulmonary haemorrhage, many of which are thought to have a genetic basis,” Dr Bower said.

“Our study of elite horses from the past will help us trace the spread of genetic disorders into the present – and it’s also been fascinating to have some historic puzzles along the way.”

Source:  University of Cambridge Communications Office



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *